Sistema 5.1 piccole dimensioni: Wharfedale DX-1 HCP vs HK-TS16 (Harman Kardon)

[Khael]

Salve a tutti....
dopo alcune ricerche alla fine ho deciso di orientarmi su un kit simile a questi per tanti motivi (primo fra tutti estetica e sopratutto dimensioni).
Fra i 2 kit cosa mi consigliereste?
L'unica differenza è che l'HK montano in ogni cassa un doppio woofer:

Speaker System
■ Frequency response: 45Hz – 20kHz (–6dB)
SAT-TS11 Satellites
■ Midrange transducers: dual 75mm (3") cones, video-shielded
■ High-frequency transducer: 13mm (1/2") dome, video-shielded
■ Impedance: 8 ohms nominal
■ Recommended power: 10 – 120 watts
■ Sensitivity: 86dB @ 2.83V/1 meter
■ Enclosure type: sealed
■ Dimensions (H x W x D): 243mm x 100mm x 92mm
(9-9/16" x 3-15/16" x 3-5/8")
■ Weight: 1kg (2.2 lb)
CEN-TS11 Center Speaker
■ Midrange transducers: dual 75mm (3") cones, video-shielded
■ High-frequency transducer: 19mm (3/4") dome, 
video-shielded
■ Recommended power: 10 – 120 watts ■ Impedance: 8 ohms
■ Sensitivity: 86dB (2.83V/1m)
■ Enclosure type: sealed
■ Dimensions (H x W x D): 102mm x 241mm x 92mm 
(4" x 9-1/2" x 3-5/8")
■ Weight: 1kg (2.2 lb)
HKTS210SUB Subwoofer
■ Low-frequency transducer: 200mm (8") cone
■ Amplifier power: 200 watts RMS ■ Enclosure type: sealed
■ External trigger voltage: 3V – 30V AC/DC
■ Dimensions (H x W x D): 353mm x 267mm x 267mm 
(13-29/32" x 10-1/2" x 10-1/2")
■ Weight: 9kg (19.8 lb)

DX-1 CENTRE	
Description/Format	Two-way Aperiodic system
High-Frequency Drive Unit	1 x 19mm silk dome
Mid/Bass Drive Unit	2 x 75mm woven PP cones
Frequency Response	80Hz – 20kHz ±3dB
Sensitivity (1W@1M)	86dB
Crossover Frequency	3.6kHz
Recommended Amp (RMS)	30 – 100W
Dimensions (HxWxD)	122x292x123mm
Net weight	2.5kg
Accessories	Rubber feet
DX-1 SATELLITE	
Description/Format	Two-way closed-box system
High-Frequency Drive Unit	1 x 19mm silk dome
Mid/Bass Drive Unit	1 x 75mm woven PP cone
Frequency Response	120Hz – 20kHz ±3dB
Sensitivity (1W@1M)	84dB
Crossover Frequency	3.6kHz
Recommended Amp (RMS)	20 – 80W
Dimensions (HxWxD)	190x122x123mm
Net weight	1.8kg
Accessories	Rubber feet
DX-1 SUBWOOFER	
Description/Format	Active subwoofer with reflex loading
Drive Unit	1 x 200mm long-throw cone
Frequency Response	20-200Hz (+/-3dB)
Rated Power Output	70W RMS
Peak Power Output	150W
Crossover Range	30 – 150Hz (adjustable)
Line Input Sensitivity	200mv
Inputs	Stereo line in (2 x RCA-phono)
LFE line in (RCA-phono)
Stereo speaker level in
Input Impedance	Line In: 20kΩ
Signal-to-noise ratio (S/N)	86dB
Avg. Max Output @1m	110dB
Options	Auto power; phase inversion
Dimensions (HxWxD)	335x285x320mm
Net weight	8.6kg
Accessories	IEC power cord, rubber feet

Dalla scheda tecnica sembrerebbe superiore il kit HK....ma alla fine non saprei quanto fidarmi delle schede

[anttrix84]

...ho lo stesso identico dubbio...

[Khael]

non so se alla fine hai scelto, però io ho preso le Wharfedale dopo averle studiate.
Le harman kardon sembrerebbero più belle però sono probabilmente qualitativamente inferiori.
Per le wharfedale non posso che consigliarti il mio acquisto; alla fine sono molto ben bilanciate e penso che il rapporto qualità prezzo sia imbattibile