JVC D-ILA HD1 vs Sharp XV-Z21000
Questo è un match che sarebbe bello poter vedere, perchè potrebbe essere il match dell'anno, (tanto il Sony Diamond prima che esce...).
In fondo è il più pericoloso attacco al mondo dei DLP, qualora l'ultimo dei LCoS reggesse bene il confronto.
LCoS vs DLP, Sharp XV-Z21000 vs JVC D-ILA HD1 e si vedrà quale è il migliore, anche se non stanno nella stessa categoria di peso, (leggi euro), l'HD1 dato il livello del nero potrebbe benissimo reggere il confronto.
Su AVS la sfida sta per cominciare, manca solo il JVC, (e non c'è da dubitare che comincerà). Per la verità i primi fuochi si sono già avuti qualche settimana fa.
Un parere di adesso:
Originariamente inviato da Mark Petersen.
I think that TomHuffman's surmise is pretty accurate, the biggest strength of the Sharp is color accuracy courtesty of CMS and also ANSI CR. I would only add a few things based on what I saw in the side by side demo at the Expo. One is that the degree to which one projector is better than another in a particular area is important. For example, the difference in sharpness with 1080p video content was barely noticeable. I suspect that a resolution test pattern would show this more clearly but for video content both projectors are very close and it shouldn't be enough of a reason to sway a buyer one way or another (assuming the convergence on the JVC is okay). The difference in light output by comparison is really big. The JVC is something like 2x brighter than the Sharp in high contrast mode and the high contrast mode is the only mode a serious enthusiast would use. I also found that In dark scenes the on/off CR advantage of the JVC could clearly be seen - the darks were darker and the small bright content brighter. In bright scenes where you would expect the ANSI CR advantage of the Sharp to dominate, I didn't see that much of a difference.
I was also surprised at how much dithering noise was reduced on the Sharp, but it's still there in the darker scenes, but much more muted than DLPs in the past. For people like me who see rainbows, the RBE on the Sharp was by far it's biggest weakness, which is probably why I preferred the Marantz 11S1 as far as DLPs go.
As far as color accuracy goes, the Sharp was set up so far from D65 at the Expo that it was impossible to gauge. My assumption though is that if properly setup the Sharp's color gamut should follow the standard perfectly. Gray scale tracking is a different issue though, I'm not sure yet which projector can be setup to best track D65 across the luminance range properly.
One of the biggest risk areas for the JVC is the QC and setup from the factory, especially with regards to shading/uniformity calibration. In the past JVC has done a reasonably good job in this respect, but we can only wait and listen to the reports from early buyers while also hoping that Wm will be able to calibrate this projector to the same level of accuracy he has achieved with past projectors.[/QUOTE]
E' distante Borg cube da Milano?
Citazione:
Originariamente scritto da Locutus2k
Be, se su avsforum lo hanno scelto come rapppresentante della tecnologia dlp per "battere" il D-ILA ... ;)
Vieni a casa mia a visionare il Sim 2 HT 3000, poi ne riparliamo (porta pure anche Jason Turk di AVS :D )
